The National Trust Is A Treasure

I was reading articles last week about The National Trust recently posting information highlighting the strong  links that roughly one third of their properties have to the slave trade. Not just properties, many many artifacts. The thrust of the message was that everytime we visit these beautiful houses and admire the exquisite antique ornaments and furniture we are looking at the unjust gains of acts of oppression and cruelty. I can only applaud The National Trust for that reminder.

Horrified was I to read that some people had taken issue at the decision from The National Trust to draw attention to this subject. It seems they resent the reminders about the scandalous slave trade. This is not something new. I have been visiting National Trust properties for years and as for a long time we used to receive a journal from them featuring their properties. I definitely recall them publishing articles at least ten years ago pointing out which of their properties were owned by families who made their fortunes as a direct result of the suffering of others.

Yet some people in recent weeks have claimed to be so incensed by being “lectured” by The National Trust or having a biased presentation of British history thrust upon them that they were ready to cancel their National Trust membership. That’s right, they don’t like being reminded that much of the wealth Britain has amassed was gained through oppression and abuse. Silly, isn’t it! Or callous!

Call it what you will. I don’t see anything wrong with wanting to visit these fascinating houses. They are beautiful. I don’t see anything wrong with admiring the workmanship of the masonry, the carpentry, the artistry and all the extraordinary skill that is on display in these properties.

I am grateful for institutions like The National Trust and English Heritage that protect these properties which help to educate us about the history of this country, which includes deeply shameful pages. They do preserve a different era and it is very interesting to be able to see all of that history. But of course anyone of good conscience should recognise that there is something seriously wrong with a system that allows people to oppress others and gain riches as a result.

Even more concerning is how those riches were then used. While so many people lived in deplorable conditions in the crumbling properties on the land of those rich folk, they were sometimes using their wealth to show off. These beautiful homes and furnishings were a statement of wealth, Worse, some of them squandered their wealth on drinking and gambling. I remember when Goldfinch and I visited Stowe School…we were shocked to learn of how the fortune of the family was thrown away within a short time by two wreckless men.

of great interest

It’s not just here that history highlights crimes that have been repeated for thousands of years. The “greatest” boasters in history often were those who committed some of the most cruel acts on a gigantic scale. In many cases, wealth and fame have been gained by wicked acts.

We traipse around the stunning relics of those criminals who were revered in their day, but are now judged under the light of the generally common feeling that wealth gained by wickedness is not ok. I will continue to visit these buildings and peer at the artifacts within them, but I am very glad to be reminded that what I am looking at is not just to be admired. It is also evidence that for a very long time some people were content to amass more and more for themselves and their family, and to show off to their friends, compete for respect and admiration, whilst many many others lived in very difficult conditions.

There were some who did use their wealth to try to improve their local communities – hospitals, schools, better accommodations for their poor tenants. That can be perceived as some “righteous” us of “unrighteous” riches perhaps. I would hope that the expenditure to benefit others was not an attempt to win acclaim or be held up as a “noble”. Yeah…it would make you feel much better knowing you were being treated in a hospital paid for by a mafia godfather or a drugs baron. Nope!

Riches acquired through criminal acts then used to benefit others is still not right. No wonder the statues, streets, theatres and other public buildings named after those who profited from abysmal abuse get up people’s noses! But I do worry about the conscience of some of the wealthy. I suspect that they had a false notion that they were “divinely favoured”, perhaps fed to them by a corrupt clergy. You know the same clergy that taught that people could pay money for prayers to be said to liberate their beloved relatives from “limbo”.

I often think that much of what people have done that was obviously wrong was sometimes perpetuated by a snivelling sermon giver, who at the same time as enjoying the favour of a wealthy parishioner, made them think they could take their success as a divine blessing rather than criminal gains.

Anyway…I could write so much on this subject. The trust of my post is that I think The National Trust are doing the right thing in reminding us that so many of these beautiful houses and artifacts have a notorious history behind them. We all know that is still happens today. Modern day slavery is an enormous and global problem. As long as it still happens we need to be reminded that is is wrong to profit from dominating others with cruel oppression.

20 thoughts on “The National Trust Is A Treasure”

  1. An interesting post, Mel. The National Trust could balance their information by sharing that a lot of the wealth exhibited in these homes and places of historical interest was gleaned from the exploitation of British people who toiled in horrific circumstances in cotton mills, down mines and up chimneys. I read a quote that said the streets of London were littered with the bodies of dead infants during the Victorian era. This was a result of the Bastardy Clause in the New Poor Law of 1834 where the fathers of bastards did not have to contribute to their upkeep. Baby farming arose as a result of this law and the abuse of thousands of children. The wealthy exploited everyone, not just the slaves.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Robbie,
      There are many historical sites which show the terrible conditions that existed in the factories and cotton mills etc
      What is worrying me that in response to the National Trust report on the connections to the slave trade of the properties they manage (many local and national authorities have commissioned audits and reports on the links to slavery of any of the public statues and buildings here) some people took to the internet to indicate their anger. When I read through the comments, they were essentially trying to deny that any wrong had been committed. They seemed to think that drawing attention to the slave trade was an attack on capitalism.
      I was baffled to be honest. I thought everyone would agree that the slave trade was wrong, wrong, wrong.
      In my view though it is one part of a history of humans dominating and mistreating other humans (and animals and planet) in the name of profit and power. I don’t understand those who seem to have a callous attitude to the suffering of others. It is disturbing.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I agree. It’s important to be reminded of history even when it makes us uncomfortable. It’s good to know how far we’ve come too even though we still have a way to go when it comes to everyone being treated equally.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I may be misusing your comment space but I was sitting here writing when you gave me yet another ‘like’ and I felt I had to say thank you for taking the time to read my posts and…liking them. You are really appreciated. Wic.


  4. I agree with you that history has sides that are not normally viewed by all. It would be rare for someone to amass great fortune, build beautiful castles and homes and do it without someone toiling at the unpaid or poorly paid work. I think of the beautiful castles and manor homes in Ireland that sat on former farm land that may have been taken unlawfully.
    I think of all the plantations in the southern US that was built on the backs of slaves. We need to recognize these dark parts of our history, bring them into the light so they are not repeated, but a beautiful house filled with wonderful craftmanship is to be admired.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Humans have mistreated each other for a very long time in many parts of the earth. So sad.
      I find it hard to understand but at the same time it is sobering that being born in and growing up in a land that was enriched by the suffering of others….the quality of life I consider basic is something many millions of people only dream about.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Yes indeed, how is it that people don’t know their history anyway? Most school curriculums give some background, the media occasionally reference the past. It’s like some people are surprised. What disturbs me is that we are still in it, modern slavery is insidious and mostly hidden.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s